Pasquale's Pizza

Discover delicious, handcrafted pizzas, stromboli, breadsticks, and hoagies at Pasquale's Pizza in Indianapolis. Savor our flavorful mushroom sauce, sausage, and fresh toppings. Visit us at 3623 W 16th St or call +1 317-632-4331 for the best pizza experience!

Welcome to Pasquale's Pizza

Experience the finest dining

Pasquale's Pizza
Pasquale's Pizza
Pasquale's Pizza
Pasquale's Pizza

Located at 3623 W 16th St in Indianapolis, Pasquale's Pizza serves up a slice of authentic Italian comfort food. This gem is the go-to spot for locals craving hearty pizzas, flavorful strombolis, and satisfying hoagies. With a casual atmosphere that welcomes family and friends, it’s easy to see why Pasquale’s has carved out a loyal following. The warm ovens and rich aromas fill the air, making the wait for that first bite even more delicious.

Open for lunch and dinner, Pasquale's always finds a way to brighten any day. Don’t miss its famous mushroom sauce and signature pizza sauce—both crafted with care. With a focus on quality ingredients and a welcoming environment, Pasquale's Pizza is more than a restaurant; it's a community gathering spot.

Pasquale's Pizza features an extensive menu that satisfies every palate. From the delectable stromboli stuffed with savory fillings to the perfect hoagie sandwiches, each dish promises a taste adventure. The star of the show remains the pizza, crafted in a traditional style that never disappoints. Diners also rave about the perfectly baked bread sticks, which pair well with any meal. The restaurant's attention to quality shines through in its choice of ingredients, such as fresh onions, tangy pickles, and quality meats. Visitors can enjoy a cozy indoor space or opt for a more relaxed outdoor area when weather permits.

Pasquale's also understands the community’s busy dynamics, offering peak and off-peak dining suggestions tailored to your schedule. For those who really want a pick-me-up, the ability to customize any dish ensures that every meal meets individual cravings.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

3623 W 16th St, Indianapolis, IN 46222, United States

Phone

+1 317-632-4331

Social Media

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Pasquale's Pizza
Pasquale's Pizza
Pasquale's Pizza
Pasquale's Pizza

Pasquale's Pizza isn’t just another eatery in Indianapolis; it’s a cherished community staple that brings people together. With roots deeply embedded in the local culture, it caters to families, friends, and anyone in need of a satisfying meal. The menu presents a well-rounded selection of Italian-American classics. For those looking for something light, the salads offer fresh and crisp options, featuring the kitchen’s renowned chef’s salad, packed with flavor. If hearty meals are more to your liking, you might gravitate toward the hot Italian sandwiches.

Choices like Italian sausage and meatball hoagies deliver bold flavor in every bite. Pizza lovers won't be disappointed either, as Pasquale's prepares pies that embody the essence of Italian tradition, featuring robust sauces and fresh toppings. Busiest times range throughout the week, with Fridays at 6 PM seeing packed tables. Notably, Wednesday lunches draw the largest crowds, while the best times for a laid-back experience lie in earlier hours during the week. A family-friendly approach prevails, where sharing dishes adds to the enjoyment. Great food, a lively atmosphere, and a loyal customer base characterize Pasquale's—making every visit an adventure for the taste buds.

Pasquale's Pizza

Pasquale's Pizza boasts an inviting exterior that reflects its homey vibe. The warm brick facade, adorned with welcoming signage, draws in both regulars and newcomers. Comfortable seating options are available outdoors, perfect for enjoying a warm Indiana evening. The lively environment often hums with conversations, laughter, and the scent of baking bread wafting through the air. The ambiance invites families and friends to unwind and enjoy quality time together. When the weather permits, the outdoor area buzzes with life while providing an excellent view of the bustling street, adding to the local character.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday10 AM-10 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday10 AM-10 PM
  • Wednesday10 AM-10 PM
  • Thursday10 AM-10 PM
  • Friday10 AM-10 PM
  • Saturday10 AM-10 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

If you are in or near Indianapolis, IN looking for some authentic, made to order pizzas, subs, wings, salads then this is a must stop. The ambiance is warm and welcoming and the owners and staff are very friendly. Smaller place with some seating but set up for delivery and pick up. There is something here for everyone and everything is made from scratch and fresh. I had one of their personal pizzas and some plain wings. Very good food.

B
Brian S.

We had a last-minute birthday celebration with 12 people at Pasquale's on 16th Street, and they were amazing! We weren't sure if it would work with such a big group, but they made it happen and took such great care of us. The food was delicious and the service from Paloma and her team was outstanding. We usually go to the Kentucky Ave location, but after this experience we'll definitely be coming back here! (Would love to help them get some updated menus and flyers!)

S
Skyler C.

Wonderful food, from wonderful people. The ladies behind the counter are incredibly polite and make wonderful food. Family owned and operated, if you get an opportunity to grab their carrot cake you won't be dissatisfied! Most definitely plan to come back here. I cannot stress enough the great customer service from this restaurant.

J
Jaryd L.

I got the small pizza with extra cheese, mushrooms, and sausage. It was absolutely fantastic. The staff was friendly and prompt. Don't let the small place deter you, it's amazing!

C
Christine

Was staying at a hotel and needed to DoorDash some pizza. Checked the reviews for some local pies and found Pasquale's Pizza with some pretty consistent praise. I ordered the Meat Lovers pizza and it was fantastic! I'm picky about pizza and this did not disappoint. Everyone was fully satisfied!

N
Nicole H.

This place is in my top two favorite places for pizza. I love the pizza here and the service is great. Very relaxed atmosphere for dine in. Now I want pizza

J
Justice F.